Fear The FCS 2026 Week 11 Media Ballot

In 2025, I was invited to vote in the Stats Perform FCS Top 25 for the first time. I was beyond thrilled to accept the invitation, and like many others, I take the opportunity seriously. I am a returning voter in 2026 and, as part of the weekly process, I will provide some thoughts, reasoning, and transparency for my top 25 ballot. Below is the Stats Perform Top 25 poll submitted after the Week 11 games. The Week 10 submission can be found here.

General Thoughts

It was another week of upsets in the FCS, which caused havoc on my ballot. When an upset happens, I always like to challenge my assumptions or review if I missed anything in previous weeks. Reevaluating teams after a loss can lead to some noticeable changes, even when we have plenty of data points. That’s most evident with my top 10-15 teams. The top five were relatively easy, but lower-ranked teams beating higher-ranked teams made me question my previous rankings. Let’s start at the top of the ballot, with a new number one team.

Tarleton State is my #1 team after defeating West Florida 31-17 on the road to clinch the United Athletic title. The Texans are a perfect 11-0 and will have a stern test next week at North Alabama to stake a claim for a top 2 seed. South Dakota State jumps from 4th to 2nd after crushing Southern Illinois 52-16 on the road. The Jackrabbits are now the undisputed best team in the MVFC after this week and only have to beat Indiana State at home next week to be in the top-2 seed conversation. Montana State remains in third after a somewhat lackluster performance against Northern Colorado. The Bobcats only led by a field goal early in the fourth quarter before two touchdowns gave them a double-digit win 31-21. Lamar jumps two spots from 6th to 4th after a 45-26 win over East Texas A&M. The Cardinals will almost certainly need to win at McNeese next week to clinch the Southland, as SFA plays against Northwestern State. South Dakota also moves up two spots to 5th after a 41-30 win at home against Northern Iowa. It wasn’t particularly impressive considering UNI scored 30 points, and USD committed 9 penalties.

The next 10 spots are where it gets crazy. I moved Stephen F. Austin up four spots to 6th after a thorough 48-0 domination on the road at UTRGV. Mercer jumps six spots to 7th after an impressive 38-31 win at Tennessee Tech. The Bears held a 17-0 lead late in the first half, but TTU scored the next 17 points. If the offense played as it did against TTU, it will be a tough out in the FCS Playoffs. Youngstown State drops from 1st to 8th after a horrible defensive showing. In retrospect, the Penguins’ defensive issues were present in the last two games, but they finally caught up to them against ISU. YSU is on a bye next week, so their regular season is complete.

In 9th, I have Weber State, which moved up two spots after the 25-21 road win at Northern Arizona. Normally, I would move a team like Weber State further up the ballot, but there’s one huge issue with this team: The ugly loss at home to 2-9 Portland State, 44-41. They also have a loss against Southern Utah (5-6) on the road, but that’s not nearly as terrible. Weber State’s overall resume isn’t as strong as the teams above them, even if I’ve been much higher on them than the other voters. A ceiling does exist, even if they’ve played well since that loss to PSU. Northern Arizona falls from 5th to 10th after the loss to Weber State. I still think the Lumberjacks are a very good team.

North Dakota had a bye this week, but moved up to 11th, thanks to the teams ahead of them losing. North Dakota defeated Illinois State 49-21 at home last week, and that’s why I have them one spot ahead of them. Illinois State vaults from 21st to 12th after the 34-33 win at Youngstown State. The Redbirds looked done early in the fourth quarter, but they put up 20 points and rallied twice to win. Both teams have a similar resume, with a loss to Northern Iowa on the road. UND has a home win over South Dakota State, while ISU has the road win over YSU. Head-to-head isn’t everything, but this is a clear case of little separating the teams, so the recent H2H result is the deciding factor.

Tennessee Tech drops five spots from 8th to 13th after the 38-31 loss at home to Mercer. The Golden Eagles played well in the 2nd and 3rd quarters, but disappeared for the 1st and 4th quarters. I also have some concerns with the defense, which played terribly for the third time against decent or good teams (Mercer, Western Carolina, and Wofford). Harvard only moves up one spot from 15th to 14th after a 38-24 win at Penn. The Crimson led 17-3 late in the second quarter, but gave up 3 touchdowns in 2 and a half minutes to fall behind 24-17. The latter two were a blocked punt and a pick-six. Harvard locked up the Ivy League AQ bid, but has been too inconsistent this year to be considered a serious threat in the FCS Playoffs.

The battle for the 15th spot went to Abilene Christian, which moves up from 22nd. The Wildcats posted a 34-31 win on the road over Austin Peay, a team that was in the top 10 last week. They have 5 losses, and 4 of them are against teams I have in the top 7 (Tarleton State, Lamar, Stephen F. Austin, and Mercer). The other loss was to Texas Tech from the FBS. I’m giving them credit for a tough schedule and finally beating a highly ranked team, but also not overhyping them because they’ve shown they’re not as good as the top 10 teams. Montana was the other team I considered ranking at #15. The Grizzlies won 38-30 at home over Idaho State, but it was another questionable performance from the defense. Maybe I’m underrating just how good this offense is, a unit I already consider one of the best in the FCS. However, the defense hasn’t shown any reason to trust them in the second half of the season.

Austin Peay falls from 9th to 17th after the 34-31 loss at home to Abilene Christian. The Governors have a good win on the road at North Alabama, but lost their two biggest FCS games against Tarleton State and Abilene Christian at home. There’s a small chance that the UT Martin win could help too if the Skyhawks win the OVC title next week. Lehigh moves up one spot to 18th after defeating Richmond 21-14. The Mountain Hawks saved us all from having to read about how I don’t think Richmond deserves a spot in the top 25 for the 5th time this year.

Incarnate Word is 19th this week, moving up one spot, after defeating Nicholls 42-24 at home. UIW reminds me a lot of Abilene Christian, with losses against an FBS team (Texas State), Lamar, Northern Arizona, and Stephen F. Austin, which are all ranked in my top 10. Unfortunately, UIW does not have a win equivalent to Austin Peay as ACU does. Nevertheless, UIW is playing well right now and likely only needs to avoid a loss at East Texas A&M to make the FCS Playoffs. Dayton moves into the top 25, securing the #20 spot this week. I know I criticized Dayton last week, but the bottom 6-7 spots in the poll have been incredibly frustrating to determine each week because there just aren’t that many good teams for the top 25 this year. I went with Dayton because the 19-9 win over Butler (9-2) on the road continues to hold up well. The Flyers also defeated Eastern Kentucky 17-14 on the road early in the season. While EKU isn’t good at 3-8, a road win for PFL teams against scholarship teams is always a bonus. I’m not a fan of the 30-22 loss at Drake (3-8) or the struggles against Stetson (1-10) in the 44-34 win, but I have fewer questions about Dayton than the teams behind them.

Next up are two CAA teams, a conference which is doing everything it can to not have more than one bid to the FCS Playoffs. Monmouth drops from 11th to 21st, and Campbell falls from 17th to 22nd. Monmouth lost 29-28 at home to Merrimack on a field goal in the final seconds. This is a terrible loss for Monmouth because Merrimack’s four wins before the game were against Maine (1-9), New Haven (3-8), New Hampshire (4-7), and Wagner (3-8), and none of their wins have been by double digits. Monmouth’s saving grace is that it won the CAA AQ bid because Campbell lost to Elon 28-24. Campbell led 17-0 at halftime, but could not execute well in the second half. Monmouth will play at Campbell next week, and Campbell needs to win to be in the at-large conversation.

East Tennessee State moves up from 25th to 23rd after a 20-17 win over Wofford on the road. It was the third straight game in which ETSU played unconvincingly. ETSU plays at Mercer next week and will need a win to have any shot at making the FCS Playoffs. North Alabama makes it into the top 25 at #24 after beating West Georgia 28-7. The Lions have losses to Arkansas (FBS), Southeastern Louisiana (5-6), Abilene Christian (6-5), and Austin Peay (8-3). Their best win is over Western Illinois, which is currently 7-4 and playing for the OVC title next week. UNA hosts Tarleton State next weekend. South Carolina State is back in the poll at #25 after a 38-24 win over North Carolina Central and winning the MEAC title.

Teams That Dropped Out and Other Notables

Three teams fell out of my top 25: #18 Princeton, #23 Idaho, and #24 Central Connecticut State. Princeton got clobbered by Yale 28-0, a terrible offensive performance. Idaho lost 28-24 at home to UC Davis after surrendering a late touchdown. CCSU lost 20-14 on the road to Long Island. The Blue Devils scored a touchdown to start the second half to take a 14-7 lead, and then the offense disappeared.

Last week, I had five teams that I considered for the top 25: Albany, Bryant, Dayton, Idaho State, and South Carolina State. Dayton and South Carolina State are now in the poll after winning their games. Albany crushed Maine (1-9) 37-3 at home, while Bryant held off Sacred Heart (4-6) 31-23 on the road. Neither performance was enough to move them into the top 25, and the top 2 teams in the CAA losing against inferior teams didn’t help. Idaho State lost 38-30 on the road to Montana. The Bengals have played a tough schedule, with four losses coming against Montana (8-3), Montana State (10-1), Northern Arizona (8-3), and Weber State (7-4). All four of those teams are ranked on my ballot. The fifth loss was to Cal Poly (4-7), which isn’t looking any better. Idaho State does have the win against Utah State, but they simply haven’t won any other game that makes me think they’ll make the FCS Playoffs, even with a win against Idaho next week.

I have 7 additional teams that were considered for the top 25: Alabama A&M (8-3), Albany (7-4), Brown (6-3), Bryant (7-4), Chattanooga (7-4), Southeast Missouri State (7-4), and Western Illinois (7-4). AAMU has looked good at times, but their resume doesn’t really hold up to make the top 25 right now. Albany has the win over Campbell, but doesn’t have a second impressive win to this point. The next best would either be Stony Brook or Rhode Island, both of which are 5-6. Albany has lost to Monmouth (8-3), Princeton (6-3), and Bryant (7-4), so there’s not a “bad” loss, but more of a lack of good wins (emphasis on wins, plural). Bryant has a similar resume, with solid wins over Albany (7-4) and Princeton (6-4). The losses have been to Army (FBS), Brown (6-3), Stony Brook (5-6), and Monmouth (8-3). I think the CAA being weaker is hurting the ability to know how good these teams are. When Monmouth loses a game at home to an obviously weaker opponent, very few people will think the CAA deserves 4 bids to the FCS Playoffs.

Brown‘s three losses are to Harvard (8-1), Rhode Island (5-6), and Princeton (6-3). They have the good win over Bryant (7-4) and a decent win over Yale (5-4), but the depth of the resume just isn’t there for them. Chattanooga lacks a signature win, with okay, but not good, victories over Western Carolina (6-5) and Wofford (5-6). They have losses to ETSU (7-4), Mercer (9-2), and Tennessee Tech (9-2) in conference, but also have a terrible loss at Eastern Kentucky (3-8). SEMO and Western Illinois have similar resumes. SEMO doesn’t have a good win other than the win over WIU, while having three FCS losses to Gardner-Webb (3-8), Southern Illinois (5-6), and West Florida (4-5). WIU’s FCS losses have been to Illinois State (8-3), North Alabama (7-4), and SEMO (7-4). WIU doesn’t have a bad loss like SEMO, but they don’t have a good win. Their best victory is probably UT Martin (5-6), and they also have the H2H loss to SEMO. Between the bottom six spots in the top 25 and these 7 additional teams that I considered, there are plenty of choices to make, with valid arguments for and against each team.

RankTeamPrevious Week
1Tarleton State2
2South Dakota State4
3Montana State3
4Lamar6
5South Dakota7
6Stephen F. Austin10
7Mercer13
8Youngstown State1
9Weber State12
10Northern Arizona5
11North Dakota14
12Illinois State21
13Tennessee Tech8
14Harvard15
15Abilene Christian22
16Montana16
17Austin Peay9
18Lehigh19
19Incarnate Word20
20DaytonNR
21Monmouth11
22Campbell17
23East Tennessee State25
24North AlabamaNR
25South Carolina StateNR

Photo Credit to Mercer University Athletics